Working Moms’ Tips on Using Grandparents as Caregivers
This post may contain affiliate links and CorporetteMoms may earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Either before or during the pandemic, have you considered using grandparents as caregivers for your kids? If you’re doing it, how is it working for your family — and if you’re hesitating, what are your biggest concerns? After all, depending on your relationship with your parents and/or in-laws, it can be a comfortable, convenient arrangement or a source of conflict, or sometimes both. Our Week in the Life of a Working Mom series has become a reader favorite over the years (and we’re always looking for submissions!), and we’re taking advantage of the many posts we’ve published to highlight the info and advice these working moms have generously shared. Our first topic was working moms’ tips on how to manage au pairs, and today we’ll share Week in the Life reader tips on using grandparents for childcare.
Here are six working moms from our Week in the Life series who have used grandparents as caregivers:
- O., a communications manager in Arizona, with a husband who is currently a student and one daughter (6 months)
- L., an appellate attorney for the federal government in Washington, D.C., with a husband who is a biotech executive and two sons (ages 3 and 5)
- C., a family law attorney for a small town firm in Minnesota, with a husband who is a guidance counselor and three kids (ages 3 months, 3, and 5)
- Em, an in-house attorney for a corporation in the Midwest, with a husband who is a project manager and one son (age 2)
- C., a corporate auditor in Texas, with a husband who is a doctor and two daughters (ages 4 and 8)
- Christa, a doctor at an academic medical center in Florida, with a husband who works in IT and a daughter (2.5 years old)
{related: grandparents as caregivers}
Details on Family Arrangements with Grandparents as Caregivers
Here are some of the details of the arrangements these families have with grandparents (as well as other family members):
- A grandmother picks up the kids three school days a week, which includes driving them to activities. She is compensated for gas and given a credit card for kid-related expenses (events, supplies, dinners/snacks). She brings the kids home to give them dinner, help with homework, and do the bedtime routine, and she also does school drop-off one day a week.
- A grandmother cares for children in her home on weekdays, usually 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.
- Many family members live in the same neighborhood as the reader and her husband: her sisters and their husbands and children, her brother and his children, two grandmothers, and many aunts, uncles, and cousins and their children. (Wow!) The reader’s older sister cares for her kids during the school year (Monday–Thursday). When she works from home on Fridays, her mom or one of her sisters will take care of her kids when she has important work calls.
- One set of grandparents babysit during the reader’s weekend volunteer work (the times her husband joins her), as well as when she and her husband spend time with friends, sans kids.
- A set of grandparents (who live two hours away) provide emergency childcare.
- A grandmother flies in from out of town to stay with the reader’s family during busy work times when she and her husband need extra help — about two months in total in a year, e.g., for a month at a time.
Thoughts from Working Moms Using Grandparents as Caregivers
Here’s what the readers had to say about using grandparents (and other family members) for childcare:
- “I work for a global company and my role requires travel across the world; if not for being able to leave my children with family I’m not sure I could hop on a plane to Europe or Asia and feel comfortable being so far away.”
- “We’re unbelievably lucky that my mum is so close and available to watch our daughter during the week.”
- “Grandparents typically have a different parenting style than parents do, which is confusing for the kids to have different sets of rules. The way a mother parents her children is a non-negotiable to the mother, and when disagreements about parenting style come up with a caregiver they might be more easily resolved when the caregiver is not family. This can be a source of tension but at the end of the day I think the benefits outweigh the challenges.”
- “[Our kids] will be ‘parented’ [by my sister] the same way that they are in my home, they play with their cousins all day, and they spend time almost every day with my parents and two of my grandmothers. In the last six years, we have only run into a few situations where I had to have uncomfortable conversations with my sister regarding childcare-related issues. At the end of the day, there is no one that I would rather have my kids with while I am at work.”
Have you used grandparents as caregivers — or other relatives? How has it worked out? What are the pros and cons? What advice do you have for other working moms interested in having grandparents as caregivers?
Stock photo via Stencil.
We decided NOT to use my in-laws for a couple reasons:
1) My husband wasn’t comfortable telling them no if they wanted to do something different than our preference, but not damaging. Like if we wanted to offer a veggie at every meal, there was no way they were going to comply with that, and he wouldn’t have felt comfortable pushing it.
2) They had just retired and didn’t understand the limitations of being our primary childcare option. As in, they couldn’t agree to take friends to the doctor in the middle of the day, or just take off on a two week vacation, without lots of discussions with us and advance notice. We needed reliable care every day for the full workday and would have a hard time finding a sitter (or taking off work) for random afternoons once or twice a month.
3) We are both extroverted and active and turns out our kids are too. We felt strongly they needed interaction with other children and playgrounds for the major part of each day. My in-laws thought spending most of the day in the (finished) basement, with maybe a storytime at the library every few weeks, would be sufficient. (See number 1 again)
They were really hurt when we told them no, even when we explained these reasons, which only further reinforced that they weren’t the right choice for our every day option. They are our backup care (at least, pre-covid) and those days work well exactly because it’s only once in a while.
We’ve never used grandparents as regular childcare, primarily because neither set of grandparents is retired or local to us, and they had no desire to change these things when our daughter was born 2.5 years ago (and in the case of my in-laws, I wouldn’t want them to). Plus we wanted daycare for socialization, since we planned on being one and done, and have been very happy with that arrangement so far. My parents plan to retire and move here in two years. When they first move here, our daughter will still be in daycare, so we’ll keep her enrolled there full-time and let my parents pick her up early whenever they want (I’m guessing it’ll be once or twice per week when they’re not traveling), which I think will be nice for them and her. Once she’s in elementary school, they want to be her primary aftercare and summer care. We’ll cross that bridge when we come to it, and of course things could change in the interim with their health or something like that, but if they’re still as active as they are now, I can see it working out well. My husband has a very flexible job and works primarily from home, so while he needs regular aftercare and summer care to get work done, it won’t be a problem for them to take the occasional vacation where he has to cover the afternoons. And we’ll probably put her in some summer daycamps for socialization and educational reasons and can time those with their vacations, which they plan WAY in advance (pre-pandemic, they were giving me info about their 2022 travel schedule).
I don’t anticipate a lot of conflict over her care. I’m a stickler for safety, but so are my parents. I don’t really care what she eats, and my parents are way more pearl-clutchy about things like screentime than I am. My attitude is that they raised me and I turned out fine, so they can use their judgment with her (barring specific safety rules that have changed since the 1980s, like keeping kids rear-facing for longer, and when I tell them about these new rules they always follow them).
Of course the current situation is totally different, and I’m super jealous of anyone who has grandparent childcare, or any childcare at all, right now. Most of my close friends are of Asian descent and have local parents living with them or that they “quaranteamed” with, and it’s straining my friendships. I’m bitter that they have free childcare and can see grandparents, and they’re judgy about the things I’m doing or planning to do that they perceive as dangerous to the public health, like sending my kiddo back to daycare.
I just want to say that I’m jealous of anyone for whom it’s an option. We have one set who lives near our neighborhood who could provide emergency care (pre-COVID) in an absolute pinch for our oldest, but not our youngest. They have serious mobility issues and cannot keep up with active kids for any length of time. I also have issues with how my FIL talks to our kids, anyway. What he calls “being PC” and I call “being decent and recognizing that these are children.”
My parents live 50 miles away and could not provide daily childcare. I rarely ask them for backup care because it’s completely on my mom’s terms and makes more work for us (one example is being completely anxious about following any sort of protocol for pickup/dropoff at school — it confuses her). The irony is that she is a recently retired preschool teacher and was very good at the teaching part of the job. And my kids adore her.
I’m good with paying for daycare, before/after care, and sitters.
We’re planning to rely upon grandparents for care in a week when ‘school’ (online, of course) ends. We are very lucky to have two sets of healthy (though older) grandparents in town, so for the summer we’re going to ask each set to take two 6-hour shifts per week so DH and I get some work-from-home done without interruption. I’m comfortable with this because we all share similar goals and values around safety, education, screen time, and meals – and most importantly at the moment, we’re all following the same social – distancing guidelines around masks, grocery delivery, etc.
The trickier question for us comes when (if?) school starts up again in the fall. Even if school does certain things like keep the kids to a single room all day (no joint cafeteria time, small groups at recess, etc.) having the additional exposure to all of those other kids will place grandparents at far greater risk if we ask them to continue with any childcare after school or on school closure days. But the thought of going from regular days with Grandma and Grandpa to none at all once school starts is pretty heartbreaking. Other options for care include the after-school care program we’ve relied upon for years (which will exposes kids to the entire schools; worth of germs) or adjusting our own work schedules so we’re available in the afternoons beginning at 3.
Ugh. As if working parenthood weren’t challenging enough before all of this …